Goodfellas Pizzeria

Nice and fresh , beautiful pizza , definitely my go to place for pizzas .

Lots of people are complaining about their food taking too long. It's not really happened to me. This rating is based on the food. Pizzas are amazing, toppings are generous & tasty, & that garlic sauce they top on some of their pizzas, absolutely to die for. 5/5.

I dont need to know the story of why you are short staffed. If you cannot deliver on time you can ring or SMS me to advise of the delay. 30 minutes late on a promise of 15 minutes late just does not cut it.

Really nice Pizza place. Gourmet range is pretty good. I love my Veggie Pizza with Pesto swirl. Tucked away gem in Greystanes / Pemulwuy area.

Great steak sandwich/ burger 👍

Worst pizza ever they use fake accounts to rate their food online and on google 60 bucks for burnt pizza and over salted pizza

Really unhappy. The last few times we have ordered the delivery time has been more than 1hour. Even after being quoted that it should only take 40mins. With delivery our pizza + garlic bread and a drink was $30. That amount for one pizza and very slow delivery is just not acceptable. Not to mention after calling and checking we were told 10 mins more and another 20 mins actually past. Only to be told its because we live 8km... when in reality its only 5.5km and they assured us they could deliver. Just lazy and unacceptable customer service.

I've pretty much sampled all the pizza places around Greystanes. This is hands down the best pizza in the area.

To keep it easy to compare I always try 'supreme' for toppings and for the purpose of reviewing, the Goodfella’s Special is as close to the standard supreme you can order from Dominos or Pizza Hut. However, try asking for a garlic base (additional) and this becomes the best version of the supreme pizza you can get. The base is thin and just right, the flavors are balanced well, full olives provide the extra salty taste this pizza needs and the garlic base really completes it. Love it love it love it.

Oh and the Mexicana is amazing too. This is probably the only pizza I still enjoy cold. They need to sell frozen versions of this one because I would probably stock it.

I've regularly ordered both of these for the last 3 months and I've observed these guys are consistent. Well deserved 5 stars from me.

Love it